Despite my persistent writer’s block and overall lack of creativity due to the ongoing stress of big changes in my life (including but not limited to my health and impending divorce) today I cannot just sit here. Today, I have something to say.
Ye be warned: strong opinion to follow.
Maybe it's just me. Maybe I just don't get things that 'most people' do.
Could be. If you’ve read here before, you know that I’m not really big on ‘mainstream successes’.
I bailed from Facebook in May and am grateful for the clarity, understanding, and truth doing so has brought into my life. When times are rough, you find out who your real friends are right quick. (One more quick thing on that- I did smile when I read that apparently about seven million other people got fed up with FB about the same time and bailed in May too so I guess it wasn't just me.)
You also know that thanks to Snooki and the Kardashians I no longer have any feelings of inferiority as a writer when it comes to the fact that my life’s work as a storyteller may never be deemed marketable enough to be printed by one of the big houses. I'm not worried about finding an agent. I don't need industry validation of my art. It is what it is, and it's mine.
As of today I no longer care if my work ever finds a large, mass-market audience. Granted, that wasn’t a big concern of mine to begin with- but now it means even less. Now, when it comes to being a bestselling author, I have completely and officially stopped caring.
Why?
Because if this is what's selling, what is popular, and what is considered funny or cool, then I don't want anything to do with it.
I saw an opinion piece on CNN.com today that made me look not once, not twice, but fifty times at least, eyes impossibly wide, jaw hanging open. In that sickening, heartbreaking moment I saw just how low people now go as far as what they believe constitutes a humorous book worth buying.
I speak of a new, "hilarious" (not my word for it certainly but I have several others...) storybook parody basically written by a disgruntled parent for other disgruntled parents: the title of which I will not even say here for fear of giving the thing more press.
To me this is so vile, so evil, so absolutely disgusting I am seeing red. I have this reaction as a woman who, as a child, was aware every day of her life that her parents often wished she’d evaporate and knew if she didn’t stay out of their way she would feel the sting of that sentiment physically without reason and without warning.
It also disgusts me as a parent who has never, EVER, no matter how tired, how sick, how weary, or how upset with my child’s refusal to lie down and cooperate with bedtime proceedings would ever THINK let alone WRITE DOWN a sentence as demeaning, at worst dangerous and at best passively-aggressively violent, as the one that makes up not only the ‘poetry’ in this book but also its unfortunate title.
Think I’m upset about this? You’d be right.
I was determined to find out who published this...thing...ready to make another snarky comment on the taste of the major publishers. My bad for jumping to conclusions. After looking it up, I found out it is an independent publisher (and I again will not use the name because they deserve no more attention for this unless it's a warning to writers that if they go with these people the 'author' of this book will be one of their contemporaries.)
I feel I not only have to bow down with gratitude to those I know out there who are running respectable, quality small publishing houses for passing on this but also forgive (just a teensy bit) the Big Guys for the Kardashians and Snooki ‘cause damn, people, even they had the sense not to publish this horrible book.
I had hoped that the only person foolish enough to actually release something this toxic into the world might be the person who wrote it thinking it was funny to begin with (and 'they' say that self-publishing authors are unprofessional…) but nope.
Someone else actually looked at this, considered it amusing enough to publish and now, the thing is at the top of the most prestigious bestseller list there is.
What is the world of writing coming to?
I don’t know. However I do know this.
If you think this book is so funny, would you still think so if your child found it, mistaking it for a real storybook, read it aloud one broken word at a time in those halting, new-reader sentences, and then looked up at you and realized that at some point you’d felt so much hostility toward them that you’d actually spent money to buy it?
If you can answer yes to that, then I truly pity your children. And wish you’d been more responsible about your birth control choices because anyone who can look at their kid and think such thoughts toward them really shouldn’t have had any to begin with.
As far as the actor that has apparently narrated the audio version (if I’m reading the news right…) don’t even get me started.
People really should think a little about the affect of their thoughts on their behavior, and what that behavior can do to their children.
Parents who foster such deep resentment even beneath the surface may really believe that the kids don't know it, but you’d be surprised. Kids are perceptive, you can't bullshit them. They're way too smart.
Someday, parents that have so little patience and that much resentment in dealing with their children just being children may find that there is a ‘book’ written for them too by their adult kids: “Mom and Dad's New Life at the Nursing Home”. Count on it.
Some may call this book ‘honest’.
Honestly, if you feel that close to the end of your rope in dealing with your kids- get help. Now. Before you say or do something that you can’t take back.
Because once your child realizes this is how you feel they will never, ever, look at you the same.
Trust me on this.
I never did.
Tuesday, June 28, 2011
13 What say you to that?:
Thank you so much for taking time out of your day to share a few words!
Please note that due to my health/limited use of my eyesight I can't always answer every comment, but I always do my best and every one will be read.
Comments may be answered on the blog or via email depending on my health on a given day, so if there is no email linked to your Blogger ID, I might not be able to find you!
xoxo bru
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Oh, Barnes and Noble had this book sitting out on display at their info desk the other day. I picked it up and read it. Not funny. Not funny at all. :(
ReplyDeletePS: Though now I see that it's going to be made into a film by Fox 2000 Pictures so maybe I spoke too soon, being forgiving of the big boys for their sense on this one...
ReplyDeleteI'm going to be sick. Seriously.
~bru
Thank you Joy, for commenting. I wondered if anyone would, and I appreciate you doing so, so much. I thought maybe it was just me. I'm so glad it's not.
ReplyDeleteI just read this in Time magazine online: apparently, this book started as a Facebook post...yet again, my choice not to stay on Fakebook is reaffirmed.
~bru
OH my goodness. I hate to comment again on my own post but it just gets worse. A quote from the 'author' from a Time magazine online article: "We are really fortunate that people decided it was worth owning. It is an art object, the kind of book you buy as a gift."
ReplyDeleteAll I can say to that is, "Not to me, pal." If anyone gave me this as a gift, I'd 'lose' their contact info, immediately. I just don't know how much sicker I can get about this after reading how many countries it's been published in...and sold well in.
What is the world coming to?
~bru
The language on the inside of the book gets worse than the even the title. I guess some people find it funny in an "all the things you wish you could say to your kids but can't" sort of way. But I don't see the humor b/c I teach kids every day whose parents really talk to them like that.
ReplyDeleteAs a kid who was treated like that even if the words weren't spoken, Joy, thank you for caring about the kids that you teach, and the little hearts and minds within them.
ReplyDeleteHostility from parents- spoken or not, damages little souls. I know from personal experience, and I'm still trying to deal with the aftermath in adulthood. Thank you, for the work that you do. The children of this world need all the caring people in their lives they can get- especially with parents like those.
hugs
bru
One of the teachers at the school my kids go to posted something about it on Facebook a few weeks ago. I didn't see the post, because Facebook took it down. More than once. I saw her post being mad about the fact that Facebook kept removing her post.
ReplyDeleteI have no real comment about the book having seen nothing of it beyond the title.
Completely unrelated, though, I just emailed you! heh I sent off the email, popped onto blogger to start my next post, and here's a pot by you! It's good to hear from you :)
I've been a bit AWOL due to having some part time work so I'm catching up the best I can, my lovely Bru.
ReplyDeleteI saw an ad for this book the other day and I thought it in very bad taste. Same as you I could not imagine a child trying to read this.
Something is wrong when we preach education and then hand our children a book like this to learn by.
God I hope you are hanging in there because I have been a very bad friend. I'm here though and always will be should you need. :)
Jules @ Trying To Get Over The Rainbow
standing up and cheering for you once more. can you hear the applause coming all the way from AZ?
ReplyDeleteI was shocked from the first time I saw the title of this book. That parents would find it funny is kind of disturbing. Maybe the people buying it don't actually have kids?
ReplyDeleteOne last thing I just have to say- and since it's my blog I can still do that- is this.
ReplyDeleteIf this book was written as a 'romantic parody' in which a man demeaned a woman the way that children are in this book- (I could give you a hundred mock titles for such a book but I won't because again, I don't want to give this thing any more attention) would it be 'funny' too, given what we know about verbal abuse leading to domestic violence?
These things escalate. It starts with thoughts. It moves to language. Then it is a very quick trip before it becomes actions. The cycle must be broken before it gets there. I just don't believe this book is a harmless stress release for otherwise loving parents. I don't buy it. The most loving parents I personally know all seem to be pretty horrified by the content.
I also know that the tone of voice I heard that particular actor use when reading excerpts from the book on a late night talk show is the same tone I heard in my parent's voices before they hit me.
Whether or not the curse words were used- the tone is there, and I don't care how old you get, if you've ever been treated that way- you don't forget how that tone makes you feel.
Hell, if this book was about someone thinking these thoughts about their companion animal people would be up at arms (I know I would.) Would people who work with abused animals at the ASPCA think it's funny given what they see every day? I don't think so. I wouldn't be amused by someone having these thoughts about an animal, let alone a child.
It really scares me to think that there are people out there actually standing up for this and worse- saying that those of us who don't find it funny have no sense of humor. I think anyone who knows anything about me knows I pride myself on mine- and that I have the ability to generally amuse most people pretty much everywhere I go.
What ever happened to kindness, and for people to just say you know what, this crosses a line? What the hell happened to decency? And lest anyone here think I'm extreme in my views overall, you should know that I am very liberal. Very. That's all I'm going to say on that.
I don't know what this world is coming to but I do know that people are responsible for the energy they bring into the room-and anyone who would be amused by this is not carrying an energy on this Earth that I want to be near.
Call it an all too clear awareness and sensitivity to scars I carry from my past, if you want. Call it that I just don't know what's funny- whatever.
Whatever you call it, this is who I am, and that's all I can say. I know what is funny, and this is not it.
I think this blog will be coming to an end soon, folks...
...because I am currently working on the most important 'writing' work of my life- rescripting my future, and the rewrite is hell but the goal- real happiness, is in sight and that is what is important now.
ReplyDeleteI am really am starting to think my energy is better focused on trying to bring the kind of energy to the world that I want to see in it- instead of being pulled into the slop by my frustration with an industry that seems to sink lower, apparently to suit the taste of the mass market, every damned day.
It's time to look ahead and focus on what matters: real friends, authentic people, peace, happiness, kindness, compassion, and bringing more to this world than I take from it or anyone in it.
If the blog stays- the tone and most subject matter changes.
I just haven't made up my mind yet.
So many writers, I've found, are just so self absorbed all the time. It's about what others can do for them. Sell my book. Promote my blog tour. That's why I've promoted so rarely here- and the writers I have are people that I truly adore and would do it all for again because none of them ever asked me to.
But lately, it's just become apparent to me how many of my writer 'friends' have been only interested in me being around as long as I was of use to them, and that ends. It ends now.
So anyway. That should have been another post I suppose but to be honest, right now I really don't feel like writing one.
~bru
NOTE: Since I was accused in email of putting someone who commented in an unfair position by refusing to let them say whatever they wanted in response here even if it insulted and offended me, I have removed their comment and follow up as well to shield them from what they felt was an unflattering light and removed my follow up comment which had their first name in it.
ReplyDeleteNow they are no longer in the 'unfair' position of having felt singled out (which I did not intend to do- my follow up comments were inspired by feelings much broader-reaching than just one person's opinion on this) because I refused to let a comment they made of their own free will, which upset me considerably, stand.
No more drama, folks. I just don't have the energy.
The end.